Are the good times in consumer spending coming to an end?
REAL ECONOMY BLOG | April 05, 2023
Authored by RSM US LLP
American consumers have shown remarkable resilience as the economy has rebounded from the depths of the pandemic. Overall spending has remained robust, despite elevated inflation and rising interest rates. But that could be changing. Lower-income consumers have started to show cracks in demand, and that could spread as the Federal Reserve’s rate hikes and recent banking instability take their toll.
The following aims to analyze where consumer spending has been concentrated over the last three years, the difference in buying power across income quartiles and other macroeconomic factors that will affect spending.
Consumption overview and outlook
After the initial shock of the pandemic in March and April 2020, the spread between cumulative real consumption (adjusted for inflation) and pre-COVID-19 estimates reached a trough of 18.0%, as the unemployment rate reached an all-time high, 14.7%, in April 2020. Aided by economic stimulus payments, real spending exceeded pre-COVID-19 estimates in March 2021 and continued through that December, when a resurgence of the coronavirus cut into spending. But even with that pullback, real spending increased 8.3% in the year, after a 3.0% decline in 2020. Last year, overall consumption continued to grow, increasing 2.8% in the year.
The largest beneficiary of spending over the past three years has been consumer products companies. In the five years before the pandemic, monthly spending on services like dining out, travel and home repairs averaged 65% of total monthly consumption. But since March 2020, this percentage has declined to 61%, with the balance shifting to goods.
Discretionary consumer categories have benefited from this shift as monthly wallet share percentages continue to exceed the five-year pre-COVID-19 average. For example, furniture and home furnishings, and apparel accounted for an average 2.9% and 3.1% of monthly consumption in the five years before the pandemic. In 2021, these percentages increased to 3.9% and 3.5%, an increase of 32.3% and 14.5%, respectively. Much of the demand for these goods was driven by the refinance and renovation boom in 2021 given historically low mortgage rates, as well as the shift to hybrid work and repurposing of wardrobes toward athleisure and luxury goods.
As we approach the second quarter, however, there is evidence that some of the spending on discretionary goods has begun to recede. Over the past 12 months, monthly wallet share on home furnishings and apparel has fallen from the peak in 2021, and many public statements from consumer products companies have pointed to softness in demand.
Excess savings impact
Excess savings has been a significant tailwind for consumers since early in the pandemic. Even with an estimated $1 trillion of excess savings remaining, though, this is not expected to have the same impact on consumption as it did in 2021 because nearly 75% of excess savings is concentrated among the top two quartile income earners.
Since this cohort accounts for approximately 60% of consumption, many consumer products companies are leaning into the “premiumization” of everyday products, in an effort to capture discretionary dollars from those willing and able to spend. However, as more everyday products target top income earners, this will put further pressure on lower quartile earners, who have eaten into nearly all of their excess savings based on our estimates.
Debt levels by quartile
Consumers are not known to stop spending when they should, but rather when they have to. For some income levels, that day has most likely already passed. Consumer debt levels showed year-over-year increases for all income quartiles in December 2022, with the exception of the top quartile, according to the Federal Reserve. In addition, the total consumer debt attributed to the lower two quartiles reached nearly 92%, the highest concentration of consumer debt to this cohort in 10 years. A big part of this debt, though, is attributed to student loans, and it also excludes the impact of buy now pay later, which has grown to include everyday products, suggesting some of the debt is greater than it appears.
While the most recent consumer price index experienced a top-line decline to 6.0% in February, inflationary pressures for fixed monthly categories remain elevated and continue to disproportionally affect lower quartile earners’ ability to spend, forcing those consumers to dip into savings or rely on debt to purchase everyday goods. In addition, these consumers typically do not have the benefit of a hybrid workplace and will be hurt by higher gas prices similar to last summer. There is evidence many consumers have shifted shopping patterns amid sustained inflationary pressures toward discount and club stores and products, shelf-stable food or private label goods, which indicates upper-level consumers are trading down and looking for value.
Labor and real wage growth
Finally, labor continues to be a bright spot for consumers. With the unemployment rate at 3.6% as of the latest reading, there is no shortage of open jobs. As long as consumers have a consistent paycheck, some discretionary spending will most likely continue. Further, while excess savings levels have fallen for lower-income earners, as noted above, real wages for production and nonsupervisory employees increased by 1.4% in February 2023, providing critical financial support.
While consumer spending has returned to pre-COVID-19 expected levels and some tailwinds remain, particularly for upper-income employees, it is likely a matter of when not if consumers pull back. Understanding the pressures across income quartiles will be critical in future periods for consumer products companies.
While upper-income earners continue to maintain ample savings to spend at will, and since this cohort accounts for the majority of consumer spending, overall retail sales or consumer spending growth could mask the pressures felt by other consumers. As long as inflation, especially on food, gasoline and shelter, remains elevated, lower-quartile earners will continue to face sustained financial pressure and will have to start pulling back on their spending habits, if they have not already.
Contact us at one of our locations or fill out the form below and we'll contact you to discuss your specific situation.
This article was written by Mike Graziano, Peter Cadigan, Tuan Nguyen and originally appeared on 2023-04-05.
2022 RSM US LLP. All rights reserved.
RSM US Alliance provides its members with access to resources of RSM US LLP. RSM US Alliance member firms are separate and independent businesses and legal entities that are responsible for their own acts and omissions, and each is separate and independent from RSM US LLP. RSM US LLP is the U.S. member firm of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax, and consulting firms. Members of RSM US Alliance have access to RSM International resources through RSM US LLP but are not member firms of RSM International. Visit rsmus.com/about us for more information regarding RSM US LLP and RSM International. The RSM logo is used under license by RSM US LLP. RSM US Alliance products and services are proprietary to RSM US LLP.
Johnson & Sheldon, PLLC is a proud member of the RSM US Alliance, a premier affiliation of independent accounting and consulting firms in the United States. RSM US Alliance provides our firm with access to resources of RSM US LLP, the leading provider of audit, tax and consulting services focused on the middle market. RSM US LLP is a licensed CPA firm and the U.S. member of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax and consulting firms with more than 43,000 people in over 120 countries.
Our membership in RSM US Alliance has elevated our capabilities in the marketplace, helping to differentiate our firm from the competition while allowing us to maintain our independence and entrepreneurial culture. We have access to a valuable peer network of like-sized firms as well as a broad range of tools, expertise and technical resources.